Under precedent-based law, especially English Law (English shameful enhancement), a betting agreement may not give a gambling club true blue buyer status, allowing the recuperation of taken assets in certain circumstances. In Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale Ltd, where a specialist utilized taken assets to bet at a club, the House of Lords overruled the High Court's past decision, arbitrating that the club return the taken subsidizes less those subject to any difference in position protection. U.S. Law points of reference are fairly comparable. For case law on recuperation of betting misfortunes where the washout had taken the subsidizes see "Privileges of proprietor of taken cash as against one who won it in betting exchange from cheat". An intriguing inquiry is the thing that happens when the individual attempting to make recuperation is the card shark's mate, and the cash or property lost was either the spouse's, or was local area property. This was a minor plot point in a Perry Mason tale, The Case of the Singing Skirt, and it refers to a genuine case Novo v. Inn Del Rio.